Planning Fallacy: Why Things Don't Happen | Altus Corp
Blog

Reasons why things don’t happen – Part 1

Do you experience missing your deadlines, missing your targets? Over the next few articles, we are going to look at several reasons why things don’t happen!

Reason 1. I was too optimistic.

Most people are optimistic most of the time. We tend to exaggerate our own talents, believing we are above average in our abilities to produce results. A study of a million students conducted by the College Board in the 1970s found that when asked to rate themselves in comparison to their peers, sixty per cent rated themselves in the top ten per cent! And twenty-five per cent rated themselves in the top one per cent! This study was investigating how well people thought they got along with others, but our fundamental optimism operates in many areas of our lives. Most people overestimate their ability to get things done and their ability to overcome problems.

This optimism contributes to what psychologists call the planning fallacy. This is the human tendency to make optimistic estimates of how long it will take to complete a task even when we’ve done similar tasks that took much longer than we thought they would. Not only do people overestimate their ability, they also underestimate the time required to complete the job. In the grip of the planning fallacy, people make decisions based on delusional optimism. To compound the optimism problem, people either ignore or discount important information about specific aspects of the task they are saying yes to, and don’t recognize red flags indicating it will take longer or be more difficult this time. Potential problems, breakdowns or difficulties are dismissed as not applicable, as if to say, “That won’t happen here.”

As a result, people overestimate the probability of success while overlooking the potential for mistakes. They miscalculate the time and resources required to get the job done. Instead of a clear and rational consideration of the job in front of them, they have a distorted and unrealistically optimistic view.

One victim of optimism was a new consultant who asked an experienced colleague how much time she should estimate for a project she was bidding. The consultant said the project involved five interviews, analysis of the interview data, report preparation and presentation of recommendations. All together, the consultant estimated it should take about twenty hours. But her colleague said her estimate was low, and that she should triple it to sixty hours, or at least double it to forty hours. The experienced colleague knew there would be much more involved than those bare-boned tasks. The consultant, not believing it could take that much time, submitted the project bid for thirty hours. Several weeks later, she confessed, “I should have listened to you. I told them it would take thirty hours, and it ended up taking me more than fifty.”

With an optimistic view, people believe they can do, whether or not they have investigated the details. So we say yes, relying on our inflated opinion of ourselves and our tendency to ignore problem signals. Unfortunately, once we get into the work, we run into reality. The result? We end up not doing things, and the promised work is not done by the deadline.

What’s the way out?

If we maintain a tracker of how much time things we do routinely take, we would be well aware of our planning fallacies. Our heart would tell us it takes us 4 hours but our mind would try and push for 2 hours. A simple conscious habit of planning the actual time each thing we do in a day takes at the start of the day and mapping it to how much time did we actually take to get those things done at the end of the day would make us aware of how optimistic and unrealistic we are in planning our day. If we look around, chances are it is pretty much a part of our culture.

Thank you for reading. Read Part II. CA Manan Vasa, Productivity Consultant.

Join Altus Corp's Productivity Shastra workshop at https://altuscorp.in to master realistic planning.